Guide / Construction procurement

General contractoror direct trade contracts.

A residential build can be procured in two ways: through a general contractor, who signs a single contract and subcontracts the trades, or directly with each trade, with a manager coordinating the packages. Where the project allows it, we recommend direct trades: they remove the contractor’s margin and spread the risk.

Luthier · Project ManagementUpdated September 2026.

01 / The two models

What changesbetween one model and the other.

The difference is not only price. It changes who controls the build and how much risk sits with a single company.

01

With a general contractor

You sign one main contract with the contractor, who subcontracts the trades, coordinates them and applies a margin on the works, typically 15–25% of the construction cost. Delivery is centralised in a single contract.

02

With direct trade contracts

You appoint separate work packages directly, such as services, joinery or finishes. You sign the contracts with each trade contractor and choose who works on your project. An independent manager organises the packages, compares the bids and coordinates the trades.

02 / Comparison

The two models, side by side.

General contractor
Luthier Split★
Margin on the worksMargin on the works
General contractor15-25% on construction cost15–25% on cost
Luthier SplitFixed fees · from €8,000Fixed fees · from €8,000
Design defense on siteDesign defense on site
General contractorSubordinate to the contractor's profitSubordinate to their profit
Luthier SplitIndependentIndependent
Low-cost subcontractor riskLow-cost subcontractors
General contractorHighHigh risk
Luthier SplitYou choose who's inYou choose who's in
ScheduleSchedule
General contractorTied to the contractor's cash flowTied to their cash flow
Luthier SplitRealistic schedule per packageSchedule per package
Cash pooling riskCash pooling
General contractorYour money may fund the contractor's other projectsYour money funds other projects
Luthier SplitEach trade is paid against actual package progressEach trade paid on progress
Financial riskFinancial risk
General contractorIf the contractor goes bankrupt mid-build, you lose deposits and paid certificationsIf they fail, you lose deposits
Luthier SplitNo single point of failure — each trade is paid for their own workNo single point of failure

Not a direct replacement for the general contractor. A different way to build: where technical and financial control don't compete with a contractor's own margin.

03 / The risk

Risk is not shared in the same way.

On a build, money is paid in advance or against certified progress. The question is what happens to that money if someone fails.

With a general contractor: a single point of failure

  • 01

    Every payment goes through one company.

  • 02

    The schedule is tied to its cash flow.

  • 03

    If it goes bankrupt mid-build, you lose deposits and paid certifications. One failure affects the whole project.

With direct trades: the risk is spread

  • 01

    Each trade has its own contract and is paid against the actual progress of its package.

  • 02

    If a trade fails, the impact is contained within its package: that trade is replaced and the other contracts stay in place.

  • 03

    There is no single point of failure. No individual failure puts everything you have paid at risk.

04 / Cash pooling

What cash pooling isand why it matters on your build.

Cash pooling is the practice of running several projects from one shared treasury. Money coming in from one project is used to pay the costs of another.

  1. 01

    You pay a deposit or a certification

    Your money goes into the contractor’s general account, together with the money from its other projects.

  2. 02

    The account pays whatever is most urgent

    Suppliers, payroll or subcontractors on any project, not necessarily yours. Your money may be funding the contractor’s other projects.

  3. 03

    Your build depends on the next payments in

    The trades on your project are paid when money arrives from other clients. While the contractor has liquidity, nobody notices. If it runs short, what you have already paid may not have reached the people who worked on your build.

With direct trades there is no shared account.

Each payment goes to a specific trade, for specific work, against its actual progress. Your money does not fund other projects. If a trade runs into trouble, the effect is limited to its package.

05 / The choice

When each model makes sense.

A general contractor fits if…

  • 01

    You prefer to centralise construction delivery in a single contract.

  • 02

    The project has many dependencies between trades and no dedicated coordination.

  • 03

    You do not want to sign a contract with each trade.

Direct trade contracts fit if…

  • 01

    You want to choose who carries out each part.

  • 02

    You want to skip the general contractor’s margin and keep every line item under independent technical control.

  • 03

    You prefer to spread the risk across several contracts and pay each trade against its actual progress.

  • 04

    You need visibility of bids and trade terms.

We work with both models. Where the project allows it, we recommend direct trade contracts.

06 / The method

How direct trade contracting works.

  1. 01Stage 1

    Organise

    Define packages and their interfaces.

  2. 02Stage 2

    Compare

    Review bids against a common scope.

  3. 03Stage 3

    Coordinate

    Support appointments and align trade commitments.

Clear roles. Shared direction.

You decide

Objectives, priorities and approval of decisions within your remit.

Luthier coordinates

Information, options, responsibilities and follow-up of the agreed scope.

The technical team

Design, technical approvals and professional duties under their appointments.

07 / The costs

What each model costs.

With a general contractor, the margin is part of the price of the works: typically 15–25% of the construction cost.

With direct trade contracts that margin is replaced by fixed management fees, from €8,000 with Luthier Split. The outcome for each project depends on its scope and the bids received, which are compared before any contract is awarded.

Construction cost refers to PEM: the works budget for materials and labour.

08 / FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Answers to help you make an informed decision before starting.

01Which is better: a general contractor or direct trade contracts?

Where the project can be split into packages and has dedicated coordination, we recommend direct trade contracts: you skip the contractor’s margin, choose each trade and spread the risk across several contracts. A general contractor fits when you prefer to centralise delivery in a single contract.

02What is cash pooling on a construction project?

It is the practice of running several projects from one shared treasury: the money one client pays may be used to cover costs on the contractor’s other projects. The risk appears if the contractor runs short of liquidity, because what you have already paid may not have reached the trades working on your build.

03What happens if the general contractor goes bankrupt mid-build?

With a single contract, the failure affects the whole project: you can lose deposits and paid certifications. With direct trade contracts there is no single point of failure: each trade is paid for its own work and, if one fails, the impact is contained within its package.

04What does direct trade contracting mean?

The client appoints separate work packages directly. Luthier organises the packages and coordinates procurement within the agreed scope.

05Who signs and pays the trade contractors?

The client signs the contracts with each trade contractor. Payment terms, warranties and responsibilities are set out in those contracts; Luthier’s fees are agreed separately.

06How are bids compared?

We prepare the package scope and review included work, specifications, exclusions, terms and timing on a comparable basis. The client makes the appointment decision.

07Does direct trade contracting reduce the cost of the build?

That is the aim. By contracting each trade directly you skip the general contractor’s margin, typically 15–25% of the construction cost, and replace it with fixed management fees from €8,000. The outcome for each project depends on its scope and the bids received, which we compare with you before any contract is awarded.

08Can I suggest contractors I know?

Yes. We assess their fit for the project and define their package and coordination with the rest of the team.

Let's talk.

A first conversation, with no strings, to understand your project.

Or reach us directly:
hola@luthier.pm
Your data stays with us. We only use it to reply to you.

Your data stays with us. We only use it to reply to you.