Guide / Quotes

How to compareconstruction quotes.

Three quotes that do not match almost never answer the same question. Before looking at the total, they have to be put on the same basis: the same line items with the same measurements, defined quality, exclusions in plain sight, the price of extras, schedule and payment terms. Only then is the cheapest really the cheapest.

Luthier · Project ManagementUpdated October 2026.

01 / Why they differ

Four reasonswhy three quotes give three figures.

None of them is a trick. Each company prices what it understands it is being asked for, and each one understands something different if the request is not closed.

01

Different scope

One bid includes demolition and rubble removal; another takes them as done. One includes the builder’s work around the services; another leaves it “to the owner”. Without a common list of line items, each quote describes a different job.

02

Their own measurements

If the design has no bill of quantities, or it is not handed over, each company measures its own way, sometimes after a half-hour visit. Differences in square metres become price differences nobody decided.

03

Undefined quality

“Porcelain flooring” or “premium taps” fit any price. Without a brand, a model or an agreed equivalent, the lowest quote usually carries the lowest material.

04

Exclusions and “separately”

What is not in the bid is paid later, at prices no longer negotiated. Permits, fees, services design, certifications, final cleaning, scaffolding and site facilities: each bid excludes different things and rarely says so on the first page.

02 / The common basis

What a serious comparison needs.

Comparing is not reading three documents: it is putting them in one table. For that, the bids have to answer a closed request.

What a quote requested without a basis usually brings

  • 01

    Summarised chapters and one-line descriptions.

  • 02

    Its own measurements, with no reference to the design.

  • 03

    Generic quality and a short or missing list of exclusions.

  • 04

    A total, a rough schedule and payment terms with a deposit.

What we ask for so that bids are comparable

  • 01

    The design’s line items, with their measurements, so everyone prices the same thing.

  • 02

    Defined quality: brand and model, or an equivalent accepted in writing.

  • 03

    An explicit list of exclusions, the same for everyone.

  • 04

    Unit prices, so that extras are valued at the bid’s own rates.

  • 05

    A schedule with a phased programme, not a number.

  • 06

    Payment terms tied to real progress, with a retention as guarantee.

  • 07

    Who answers for what: interfaces between trades, site facilities, cleaning, safety.

03 / The method

How we compare bids.

  1. 01Stage 1

    Level

    We prepare the tender basis: line items, measurements, quality, exclusions and conditions. It is the document sent to every company.

  2. 02Stage 2

    Request

    We request bids on that basis and answer each company’s questions in writing, with the same answer for all.

  3. 03Stage 3

    Read

    We put the bids in one table: item by item, quality by quality, exclusion by exclusion. We flag what is missing, what is surplus and what each one prices separately.

  4. 04Stage 4

    Decide

    You award with that reading. Before signing, what was clarified in writing goes into the contract: scope, quality, exclusions, unit prices, schedule and payments.

Clear roles. Shared direction.

You decide

Objectives, priorities and approval of decisions within your remit.

Luthier coordinates

Information, options, responsibilities and follow-up of the agreed scope.

The technical team

Design, technical approvals and professional duties under their appointments.

04 / The signs

How to recognise a genuinely cheap bid.

A low price is not a problem. The problem is a low price that does not explain why it is low.

Signs that the saving will be paid on site

  • 01

    Line items without measurements, or well below the design’s.

  • 02

    Quality described with adjectives and no models.

  • 03

    Many items “to be justified” or “priced separately”.

  • 04

    A high deposit and payments that do not depend on progress.

  • 05

    A schedule with no programme behind it.

Signs of a serious bid

  • 01

    It answers the design’s line items and measurements, with unit prices.

  • 02

    It states which quality it offers and what happens if it changes.

  • 03

    It lists what it excludes and what it assumes.

  • 04

    It is paid against real progress and accepts a retention as guarantee.

  • 05

    It explains the schedule by phases and what it needs from you to meet it.

Comparing with a general contractor or direct trades changes the detail, not the principle: in both cases, the same basis for everyone. How to choose between the two models is explained in another guide. Read the guide

05 / What it costs

A tender basis and an independent reading.

Preparing the tender basis and comparing bids is part of Luthier Plan, before the works are contracted. If the works are contracted by trades, the comparison by package is the job of Luthier Split.

Fees are fixed and set in the proposal. Whoever compares is not paid by the bidding companies: the reading is independent of whoever ends up building.

PEM: construction cost (materials and labour).

06 / FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Answers to help you make an informed decision before starting.

01Should I go with the cheapest quote?

With the genuinely cheapest one, which you only know once the bids answer the same basis. A low total with long exclusions or short measurements usually ends up costing more than a complete bid.

02What are exclusions and why do they matter so much?

They are the works and costs a bid does not include: from permits and fees to rubble removal or final cleaning. What is excluded is paid later, at prices no longer negotiated. That is why every company is asked for the same list of exclusions.

03How do I stop extras from inflating the price?

By asking for unit prices in the bid and fixing in the contract that extras are valued at those same rates. During the works, each change is documented with its reason, scope and impact before it is carried out, so you decide with the figure in front of you.

04Can I compare a general contractor’s quote with bids from trades?

Yes, if both are broken down by line item. The contractor’s price includes its margin, typically 15–25% of the construction cost; trade bids are added up package by package plus the fixed management fee, from €8,000 with Luthier Split. The comparison also has to include who coordinates and who answers for the interfaces between trades.

05How do you make bids comparable?

We establish a common scope and requirements, then review items, specifications, exclusions and timing to explain the differences before you decide.

06Can you join when the design is complete?

Yes. We review what needs clarification before tendering: scope, quantities, specifications, trade interfaces and schedule. The proposal reflects the actual project stage.

Let's talk.

A first conversation, with no strings, to understand your project.

Or reach us directly:
hola@luthier.pm
Your data stays with us. We only use it to reply to you.

Your data stays with us. We only use it to reply to you.